top of page
Gooseberry Gardens

Banana Pepper Honey Mustard

Writer: Jennifer Hoglin
Jennifer Hoglin
May 9, 2020
1 min read

Updated: Oct 25, 2023

This is not my most requested recipe but is, by far, the gift most requested by friends and family. I grow Hungarian Wax Banana peppers every year just to make this recipe. And more every year as the word gets out.

Use it on hot dogs or sausages, to dip pretzels in, or to baste a ham with. As my one of my very good friends says, "That s&*# goes on anything!" Brittany, this is for you. In case you ever get desperate and need to make it yourself.


Ingredients


20 banana peppers stems removed

2 cups prepared yellow mustard

2 1/2 cups white sugar

1/2 cup honey

2 cups apple cider vinegar

1/2 tablespoon salt

3/4 cups all purpose flour or Clear Gel

3/4 cup water



Directions


Using gloves, remove the seeds from the banana peppers and place in a food processor. Process until smooth.

Pour into a large pot and stir in the mustard, sugar, honey, vinegar and salt. On high, allow to boil and cook down 3-5 minutes.

Stir together the flour (or Clear Gel) and water until smooth. Whisk into the boiling mixture until smooth. Continue to boil, Stirring constantly another 5 minutes. Pour into sterile pint jars and seal with new lids and rings. Process in a boiling water bath for 10 minutes. Add altitude adjustment time if required (add 5 minutes if you are in Calgary).


Yield: approximately 7 pints


Original recipe from My Catholic Kitchen (http://mycatholickitchen.com/)


Further Information


3 Comments


Krista Gregg
Krista Gregg
Oct 07

Tried this for the first time and it turned out great! I didn't keep track of how many peppers we used, but it added up to an 8 cup pyrex measuring cup mostly full of Hungarian Wax peppers, in various shades of yellow, orange and red, that had been halved and the seeds, core and most of the pith removed. I processed them in the Ninja blender with the attachment that I would use to make a smoothie, so they were very liquefied. It added up to 2 3/4 C of pureed peppers. I added 2/3 C of honey, as it was definitely more peppers than the recipe called for. My husband and aunt reported that it has a…

Like

Amber Blagg
Amber Blagg
Jul 29, 2024

I actually didn't intend to plant any banana peppers this year, but my bell pepper seed packet seems to have had a variety of peppers in it and I've already pickled as many banana peppers as I'll eat this year, so I needed a new recipe.

I made a half recipe of this last night and I might make more! My husband proclaimed it as amazing even though we almost never eat mustard on anything. I will say that I got a bit nervous when I poured in the clear gel/water mixture and it got REALLY thick, REALLY fast. I think next time I'll add it slowly, but otherwise I am excited about adding this to my pantry!

Like

shannon.bozich
Jul 20, 2024

Should it be instant clear gel or the cook type? Thanks!!

Like
bottom of page